The 7 Best Substitutes For Cajun Seasoning - Tasting Table (2024)

Cook

The 7 Best Substitutes For Cajun Seasoning - Tasting Table (1)

Michelle Lee Photography/Shutterstock

ByHayley Hamilton Cogill/

Savory and spicy, Cajun seasoning adds a lively punch of flavor, transporting you to the southern dishes of Louisiana. The seasoning adds zesty flavor to crab cakes, blackened fish, roasted chicken, and seafood boil. The mix of spices is a staple ingredient in New Orleans favorites like gumbo, jambalaya, andétouffée.

Cajun cuisine was born out of the kitchens along the bayou, with influences from French, American Indian, Caribbean, and African cultures. The territory was declared a part of the French colonies in 1682, a gift forKing Louis 14thof France, named Louisiana in his honor (via theEncyclopedia of French Cultural Heritage in North America).However, the Acadians didn't arrive in southern Louisiana until the mid-1700s, when the British deported them from their Northeastern Canadian homes after the French and Indian War. When these French Canadians arrived, they brought traditional French roots and flavors, marrying them with local influences. The combination became the beloved Cajun cuisine of today.

As the popularity of Cajun flavors spread throughout the country in the 1980s, and pre-made spice blends started to appear on store shelves, shares Spiceography.Though there is no set recipe for Cajun seasoning, it generally includes dried herbs and spices such as cayenne, paprika, pepper, garlic, and onion. The blend gives a mouthwatering kick to your morning scrambled eggs, or when dusted over popcorn. But, Acadiana's favorite spice isn't the only spice blend to enhance your favorite breakfast, lunch, or dinner fare. Consider one of these substitutes to add zesty richness, transporting you to the French Quarter.

Creole Seasoning

Creole and Cajun foods have similar roots, though Creole has more European influences. Louisiana's Creole people came directly from France, or other parts of the world, instead of Canada, shares New Orleans.com. Creole dishes are more refined and sophisticated than Cajun, born from the international flavors of Europe, the West Indies, and Africa.

For instance, the roots of gumbo came from African stews, with the name originating from the West African word for okra, ki ngombo, and mixed with French influence (viaPelican State of Mind). The roux-base of stew is similar to a French bouillabaisse. Creole flavors are sophisticated, using tomatoes and herbs in dishes, creating rich sauces. Cajun dishes are rustic, rural, and often prepared in one pot. Creole is the flavor of New Orleans; Cajun became the flavor of the Southern Louisiana countryside.

Creole and Cajun seasoning blends have similarities, including paprika, garlic, onion, and oregano. The significant difference between Creole and Cajunseasoning is that Creole generally does not include the heat of cayenne pepper, bringing a depth of flavor without the punch of spice. The more subtle of the two seasonings, Creole seasoning is interchangeable for use in Cajun cuisine, offersSpiceography. However, add a pinch of cayenne or red pepper flakes to mimic the heat Cajun seasoning gives dishes like jambalaya or alligator stew. Use Creole seasoning as a flavor enhancer after a dish is complete on vegetables, eggs, or pasta. Or, generously sprinkle on while cooking to blacken chicken or fish. Popular brands include Zatarain's and Tony Chachere's. We like "Shef from James Beard award nominee, Tiffany Derry.

Maryland Seafood Seasoning

The 7 Best Substitutes For Cajun Seasoning - Tasting Table (3)

Bloomberg/Getty Images

No crab, shrimp, or crawfish seafood boil is complete without Maryland's favorite seafood seasoning blend, the signature spice of the Chesapeake Bay. The unconventional spice blend came from the fishing docks of Baltimore where fishermen were seasoning Maryland blue crab caught in the Bay, shares The Nosher.

Old Bay is the most common option available throughout the country, crafted over 75 years ago by Jewish German immigrant Gustav Brunn. He set up his Baltimore Spice Company across the street from the docks, blending a concoction of freshly ground cinnamon, cloves, bay leaf, paprika, and more. The fishermen loved it, as the blend gave smoky, earthy, savory flavors to sweet shellfish. Today spice giant McCormick owns the brand, opting to keep the mix of 18 ingredients in Old Bay proprietary. But, similar Maryland seafood blends include the identical ingredients found in Cajun seasoning, like onion, garlic, paprika, red pepper, and black pepper, along with clove, mustard seed, mace, cardamom, and bay leaves.

The wide range of spices adds deep, layered flavors to a dish, with more complexity than the heat-filled Cajun seasoning will give, perPepper Scale. However, the similarities between the two can make Maryland seafood seasoning an acceptable exchange for Cajun seasoning. Old Bay does not have the heat of cayenne, so you may need to add a pinch of fiery spice to create an authentic piquant flavor. Sprinkle over all crustaceans, dash on white fish or cauliflower before grilling, or dust over French fries.

Vindaloo Spice Seasoning

Some Cajun seasonings include the signature Indian spice, turmeric, which is one of the most healthy spices in the world. Healthline notes the golden-hued root can reduce inflammation and help prevent heart disease, Alzheimer's, and cancer. India's vindaloo seasoning shares similar ingredients to Cajun seasoning. With Portuguese origins, vindaloo arrived in India when explorers brought a version to the country in the 1400s with their stew carne de vinha d'alhos, or meat marinated in wine vinegar and garlic (viaSaveur). Once there, the dish began to incorporate local ingredients into the traditional spice and herb blend, adding warming brown spices to the mix. Today vindaloo is most often used in making a zesty curry. Sukhiwrites that the spice blend includes cinnamon, cardamom, turmeric, and ginger, along with the classic Cajun flavors of garlic, onion, pepper, and spicy cayenne or chili peppers. Spicy chili peppers were brought to India by the Portuguese from the Americas.

Use the spice blend when preparing a dish, verses sprinkled on at the end. The late chef, Floyd Cardoz, known for crafting authentic Indian cuisine, shared the technique of toasting (or blooming) your spices to create your blend with Fine Cooking. He shares that gently toasting the spices in a hot pan will help release fragrant, floral, savory aromas and flavors. Vindaloo seasoning can be extremely peppery and spicy, depending on the strength of the chili peppers, so adding a bit of sugar can tame the heat, making it easier to enjoy the depth of flavor the spice mix gives to dishes.

Garam Masala

Like vindaloo, garam masala is one of India's favorite spice blends. The Ayurveda Experience shares masala is the Hindi word for spice, and garam, meaning hot. The spice blend is likely from regal homes of Northern India, where cold winter temperatures required food to have the ability to warm you from the inside. This also follows the eastern medicine concept of Ayurveda, where food and health combine. The thought behind the principle is that the combination of spices will increase your body's metabolism.

The blend typically does not contain chilis or cayenne pepper. Instead, the warmth of garam masala comes from up to 30 ingredients, creating a deeply complex flavor with refined subtlety, including ginger, giving aromatic freshness; cardamom, bringing minty, citrus notes; cumin, giving earthiness; cinnamon, providing sweetness. Combining the masala together delivers health benefits like lowering blood pressure, aiding digestion, and the total blend's ability to increase your metabolism. As the mixture does not have the fiery element of cayenne, garam masala gives an unexpected savory spin to dishes similar to Cajun seasoning without the punch of heat.

Traditionally, it is best to toast whole spices before being grinding them into a powder when preparing the combination, per Indian Kitchen and Spices. When the spices are fresh and fragrant you can easily add garam masala at the end of cooking as a finishing seasoning, as you would salt and pepper, keeping the perfumed aromas bright with a note of complexity at the forefront. Try it in your next batch of jambalaya or one of ourétouffée recipes.

Adobo Seasoning

You have likely seen or cooked with chipotle peppers in adobo sauce; the small can sitting next to the salsa and hot sauce in the international food aisle. That little can packs a punch of smoky, pungent flavor thanks to the vinegary marinade of the adobo. Adobo seasoning is the Spanish and Filipino counterpart to Cajun seasoning. Adobo is from the Spanish word adobar, meaning marinade, and is much like vindaloo. Historically, adobo was a mix of spices with vinegar, used to preserve meat and pork.

The origin of adobo has been questioned over the years, per bon appetit. The name would lead us to believe it is of Spanish origin, likely from Southern Spain near the port city of Cadiz. But the Philippinesalso claim it as its national dish. Either way, when the Spanish began colonizing Latin America, the Caribbean, and the Philippines, adobo became a part of the cuisine, with each country developing its version, which is still present today.

Today, adobo sauce is most commonly used as a wet marinade for adobo chicken or pork in Filipino cooking, with the acidic sauce breaking down fatty meats and adding intense flavor. Puerto Rican and Mexican cuisine uses adobo as a dry rub for chicken and poultry, skirt steak, pork shoulder, and swordfish. With or without vinegar, the base of adobo is garlic, pepper, onion, salt, oregano, and turmeric. As adobo typically omits cayenne, be ready to add a pinch to bring the heat.

Mala Spice

The 7 Best Substitutes For Cajun Seasoning - Tasting Table (7)

Hayley Hamilton Cogill/Tasting Table

We love the spiciness of Cajun seasoning. The punch of peppery fire from the cayenne makes your tongue tingle, your head swirl, and your toes curl. If you are like us and crave a pop of spice in everything you eat, swap your Cajun seasoning for mala spice. With origins in the Sichuan province of China, mala spice brings the heat and the flavor. And we do mean heat. In Chinese, ma means numbing, and la means spicy (viaThe Woks of Life). Malaproduces a mind-numbing, mouthwatering flavor bomb, with complexity.

As hot peppers and warm spices are at the base of the blend, the seasoning creates a similar response in the body as garam masala or vindaloo, with the combination causing your body's temperature to rise, increasing your metabolism. Mala spice combines crushed, hot red chili peppers, floral, citrusy Sichuan peppercorns, and a variety of spices, including coriander, cumin, ginger, and star anise.

But mala isn't just a spicy, savory pepper blend. The seasoning often contains dried mushroom powder. This powder gives an underlying note of earthy umami, delivering a complex, satisfying combination of heat, sweet, bitter, salt, and umami, with uniquely Eastern spice flavors. Mixing mala spice with oil to use as a condiment or dipping sauce is most common, or sprinkling it on beef, poultry, or vegetables before grilling or roasting is most common. Use mala as the seasoning for your next crawfish boil or as a base for shrimp Creole.

Simply Organic All-Purpose Seasoning

If you're like us, you can dig into the back of your spice cabinet and find a jar of all-purpose seasoning. We usually buy a bottle along with poultry seasoning at Thanksgiving, use it to flavor our cornbread dressing, and then forget it is there. However, an all-purpose seasoning blend is one of the easiest ways to add a pop of savory umami to any dish. The seasoning is a blend of herbs and spices, including garlic, onion, pepper, and various dried herbs like parsley, basil, and oregano. It doesn't have the fiery heat of Cajun seasoning, as most all-purpose seasonings are sans red pepper or cayenne, but it brings the flavorful qualities of the blend.

We like Simply Organic All-Purpose Seasoning. It is salt-free and includes the typical spices found in Cajun seasoning without the heat of cayenne. Instead of heat, it adds loads of herbs. The seasoning includes dried basil, oregano, thyme, sage, parsley, and more, all grown organically. And, we like the brand, as Simply Organic is committed to helping those with food insecurity in North America. Through its Giving Fund Grant Program, the company donates to typically overlooked organizations, like produce farms helping refugees and immigrants, and food pantries helping feed inner-city kids. Any product that is good for the earth and good for our neighbors is a win-win for us.

If All Else Fails, Make Your Own

The 7 Best Substitutes For Cajun Seasoning - Tasting Table (9)

faithie/Shutterstock

Making a homemade spice blend outweighs the use of a pre-packaged option any day, outside of the convenience factor of the sprinkle-and-go container. Creating your blend will allow you to use the freshest spices and herbs, giving you the opportunity to toast any spices prior to grinding, releasing the essential oils of the spices. And, you will be able to control the amount of salt included in the seasoning. A draw-back of most premade Cajun seasonings is that it includes salt — typically a lot of it. Brands like Slap Ya' Mama, Emeril's, and Rajun' Cajun can deliver your daily recommended sodium allotment with just a few shakes of the jar.

Masterclass shares that the blend should include onion powder, garlic powder, cayenne pepper, paprika, and pepper. If you only have a few of these ingredients, some are more effective than others in giving an authentic Cajun taste. Cayenne pepper (or some hot pepper like ground annatto seeds, dried chile de árbol, or crushed red pepper flakes) will bring the heat, smoky or sweet paprika (or a combination of both) will give smoke or sweetness, garlic powder and onion powder will add savory qualities. Mixeach ingredient in a small bowl and sprinkle on. Or, even better, rim the glass of your morning Bloody Mary, and add a dash to your co*cktail. Store any remaining seasoning in an air-tight container, and place it in a cool, dark cabinet to preserve the freshness.

The 7 Best Substitutes For Cajun Seasoning - Tasting Table (2024)

FAQs

The 7 Best Substitutes For Cajun Seasoning - Tasting Table? ›

Cayenne pepper (or some hot pepper like ground annatto seeds, dried chile de árbol, or crushed red pepper flakes) will bring the heat, smoky or sweet paprika (or a combination of both) will give smoke or sweetness, garlic powder and onion powder will add savory qualities.

What is the best substitute for cajun seasoning? ›

Chili powder + dried thyme + cayenne pepper

If you really don't have many ingredients in your pantry, you can pull together a basic substitute for Cajun seasoning using 1 tablespoon of chili powder, 1 teaspoon of dried thyme and 1/4- 1/2 teaspoon of cayenne pepper.

Which is hotter, Cajun or Creole seasoning? ›

While spicy dishes are found in both cuisines, every dish isn't necessarily spicy…it all depends on how much cayenne pepper is used in the recipe. Cajun dishes tend to be a bit hotter than Creole.

Which spice is not typical in cajun seasoning? ›

For different flavors, some Cajun spice mixes include salt, mustard powder, chile peppers, or cumin. This spice mix also includes oregano and thyme, which you don't normally see in Cajun spice mixes — those are typically found in Creole spice mixes.

What is authentic cajun seasoning? ›

Everyone tends to have their own spin on it, but in general, it's a spicy blend featuring lots of paprika, cayenne, garlic powder, pepper and oregano. Various other seasonings can be added to taste.

Can paprika replace Cajun? ›

Paprika, garlic powder, onion powder, thyme, oregano, and cayenne pepper in different proportions can be a substitute for Cajun Seasoning.

Can I substitute Old Bay for Cajun seasoning? ›

Old Bay and Cajun seasoning do have differences, but in many cases they can be used interchangeably. The ingredients in the foundation of each spice make them easy to incorporate into various recipes.

Which is hotter Cajun or paprika? ›

Flavor – Cayenne is a fiery spice that adds heat to any dish, while paprika has a milder, slightly sweet taste.

Can I substitute Creole seasoning for Cajun seasoning? ›

So can you replace Cajun seasoning with Creole seasoning? The short answer is yes, MasterClass explains, as they feature many of the same ingredients. However, with Cajun seasoning being spicier and Creole more earthy, there will be a slight difference in flavor.

Is paprika hotter than Cajun? ›

Cajun seasoning is primarily salt, cayenne (red pepper), and garlic powder. It is hot and salty. Paprika can be mild, hot, or smoked but is predominantly a mild red colored pepper in dried and powdered form. It contains no salt and has a very mild flavor (except for the hot variety).

What can I use instead of cayenne pepper in Cajun seasoning? ›

Hot paprika is a common cayenne pepper substitute at most grocery stores. Although these two seasonings aren't identical, they both come from chilies and are similar in color.

Is paprika like Cajun? ›

Because Cajun has both spicy (paprika, chilli and cayenne) and earthy (garlic, oregano and other herbs) it's an all-purpose seasoning that works with many different flavours. You can learn more about Cajun cuisine here.

Is Cajun the same as Creole? ›

Today, common understanding holds that Cajuns are white and Creoles are Black or mixed race; Creoles are from New Orleans, while Cajuns populate the rural parts of South Louisiana. In fact, the two cultures are far more related—historically, geographically, and genealogically—than most people realize.

What is the Holy Trinity in Cajun cooking? ›

The "holy trinity" in Cajun cuisine and Louisiana Creole cuisine is the base for several dishes in the regional cuisines of Louisiana and consists of onions, bell peppers and celery. The preparation of Cajun/Creole dishes such as crawfish étouffée, gumbo, and jambalaya all start from this base.

What spices are in McCormick Cajun seasoning? ›

Our Cajun-style spice brings robust flavor to your cooking with herbs and spices like paprika, thyme, garlic, celery seed and red pepper. Taste our seasoning and dive into Cajun culture, even if just for a moment. It's a flavorful, spicy way to serve chicken, shrimp, fish, rice and more with Louisiana-style flair.

What are the three main ingredients in Cajun cooking? ›

As far as ingredients ago, these three sound simple as can be. Bell pepper. Celery. Onion.

What is cajun seasoning made of? ›

Cajun seasoning is a blend of spices originally from Louisiana, made popular by the wonderful flavor of Cajun cuisine. You'll find many variations, though typical ingredients focus on paprika and cayenne, along with garlic, onion, salt and a potential slew of other ingredients, like dried herbs and spices.

Is paprika the same as Cajun? ›

Can I Substitute Paprika for Cajun Seasoning? I like smoked paprika in my Cajun seasoning, but you can use unsmoked, or sweet if you prefer. If you only have a few ingredients 1 tablespoon Paprika, 1 teaspoon of mixed herbs, and a pinch of chilli flakes or powder and salt and pepper could work well.

Can you substitute Creole for Cajun seasoning? ›

So can you replace Cajun seasoning with Creole seasoning? The short answer is yes, MasterClass explains, as they feature many of the same ingredients. However, with Cajun seasoning being spicier and Creole more earthy, there will be a slight difference in flavor.

Is Cajun seasoning similar to chili powder? ›

Cajun seasoning is not the same as chili powder. Chili powder typically contains cumin, but cajun seasoning does not. Chili powder also has much less salt. They are not similar enough to use them interchangeably.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Nicola Considine CPA

Last Updated:

Views: 5628

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (49 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Nicola Considine CPA

Birthday: 1993-02-26

Address: 3809 Clinton Inlet, East Aleisha, UT 46318-2392

Phone: +2681424145499

Job: Government Technician

Hobby: Calligraphy, Lego building, Worldbuilding, Shooting, Bird watching, Shopping, Cooking

Introduction: My name is Nicola Considine CPA, I am a determined, witty, powerful, brainy, open, smiling, proud person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.