Homemade Shamrock Shake Recipe - Baker by Nature (2024)

A super easy homemade version of the famous Shamrock Shake! Sweet, creamy, minty goodness in every sip.

Hiiii! I’m kicking off this post with a question for you: have you ever had a shamrock shake? You know, those pale green, minty milkshakes, released at McDonald’s right around St. Patrick’s Day…? I am no fast food junkie, but they have long been my weakness! If you’ve ever had one, you know the struggle is real.

This year I decided to ditch the drive-thru and create a homemade version we can all enjoy!

This shamrock shake is:

• thick and creamy
• perfectly sweet
• slightly minty
• totally refreshing
• made with just 5 simple, everyday ingredients
• ready in minutes
• easy enough for the kids to help make
• wonderful for St. Patrick’s Day celebrations
• delicious with a shot of vodka or bourbon added into the mix… if you’re looking to get boozy
• and impossible to resist!

Ingredient wise you will need vanilla ice cream, pure peppermint extract, whole milk, confectioners’ sugar, and green food coloring (optional!). That’s it! I also throw in a few fresh mint leaves, but unless you really love the texture/taste of raw mint, I wouldn’t suggest doing this. The peppermint extract adds plenty of flavor without messing with the texture! I love Star Kay Pure Peppermint Extract, if you’re in the market for a new bottle.

If you do not use food coloring, please feel free to leave it out of this milkshake. It will still be delicious, and you can add a fresh mint sprig on top for a vibrant pop of color. You know I’m all about that pretty presentation.

Since this recipe is extremely minimalistic, I recommend using your favorite vanilla ice cream, as the flavor really does shine through.

Simply blend and serve! Top with a generous dollop of whipped cream for an extra indulgent dessert.

A fun and festive creamy treat ready in just minutes! No drive-thru necessary 😉 Happy sipping!

If you try this recipe, let me know! Leave a comment below and don’t forget to snap a pic and tag it #bakerbynature on Instagram! Seeing your kitchen creations makes my day. ♥

Other Posts You May Like